Loyalty to an employer is real but secondary. When profit, schedule, or a gag clause conflicts with public safety, health, or welfare, the PE follows Canon I. Refuse unsafe directives, notify in writing, and escalate if the public remains at risk. Being fired does not make the unsafe choice ethical.
Canon I
Hold paramount public safety, health, welfare
Loyalty
Duty to employer, ranked below the public
Record
Written notice of the safety objection
Step-by-step solved example
An employer orders a cheaper, undersized beam to hit a budget, over the PE's objection. Occupancy is public. Action?
1. Conflict
Employer profit versus occupant safety.
2. Canon I
Refuse to seal the unsafe member. Notify the employer in writing. If they proceed, notify the building official.
Answer: Public safety wins: refuse, notify, escalate if needed.
10 practice questions
0/10 correct
1.When employer profit conflicts with public safety, the PE follows
2.Canon I requires engineers to
3.An employer orders a cheaper unsafe detail. You should
4.Loyalty to the employer
5.If fired for refusing unsafe work, the ethical stance was
6."The public" includes
7.A gag clause cannot
8.Documenting a safety objection in writing
9.The client wants to skip required inspections. You should